[13] Kyle Kelley: Okay, we're good. [17] spk10: And here's the [43] spk5: where we are is that way we're just waiting for co terror to call us to that order. [50] Mike Edgington: Excellent. So are we recording excellent, thank you. Okay. I will call the meeting to order at 1132. read some couple of statements and then ask one of my fellow supervised to read the land use choosing to do so. The good board of supervisors committees or subcommittees are subject to the Alaska Meetings Act as Alaska statute 44.62.310 and anchorage municipal code 1.25 public meetings. Good board of supervisors operates under the Goodwood public meetings standards of conduct. [106] Brian Burnett: Thank you. Community of care situated between the areas known to be Dana and Alpic Homeland respects the people who are stewards of this land for generations. We commit to the continued stewardship of this land and are grateful to be part of a wider community that seeks to maintain a sustainable use of Kirkwood Valley for present and future people. Thank you very much. [138] Mike Edgington: I'll actually ask his staff to do the role call. I think that's the way we should be doing it. Okay. [145] Kyle Kelley: Present. Brian Burnett. President. Rihanna Sullivan. [152] None: Yeah. [155] Mike Edgington: Okay. Thank you. General Visions and approval. Motion to approve tonight's agenda or today's agenda. Okay. Second. [167] None: Second. [167] None: Second. [169] Mike Edgington: Okay. I think there were two seconds. So second or third. Any adjustments? [175] Jennifer Wingard: Yes. I know if I mean one of the petitioners, it wouldn't be able to come for the first half hour. So I don't know how the board feels about it, but we could move item number one to later in the agenda itself is I hope he would personally appreciate [189] Mike Edgington: it. Okay. I was actually gonna I was gonna suggest in a moment to move two before one. So maybe that would work. Maybe we can do two, then three, then one. Okay. is there anyone who's a who objects to moving item three, two first, then three, then one. So we move item one to the end. Not hearing any seeing any objections, we'll do that by assent. Okay. So now we can move on to the agenda. We will start with item number two. Section line easement appeal for GBSA. So which supervisor is is going to be the primary person on this. We have a supervisor generally who produce these things in schools and [239] Jennifer Wingard: I'm happy to do that section. Okay. So I'm gonna acknowledge first of all that I know that we all heard the presentations and discussions at OUCS, all members of GBOS at that meeting. So I'm not gonna fully rehash everything. So which version here is that this is a proposed response to the N star approval for M Star to go ahead and put in a second line along their easement, which sort of triangulates the value from the old Gerg area over to studio near the top chapter line. And I don't know if there's anything else that seems to be said me on that. This is lengthy packet that I know as I said that we've all seen before. So yes. [299] spk5: on the top of the printed packet, which I didn't do all 99 pages. So yes, you're missing things from what is in the online packet. But what I put on top is the actual decision or the first couple pages of it. And I really think that it would help GBOS to stay focused on what is at hand with looking at what the scope of the decision was. And so that's the top of the packet. The scope of the decision is kind of three quarters of the way down. And basically it says that there the state of Alaska DNR is determining whether or not this is an acceptable use of an easement. And that's all. [351] Mike Edgington: Thank you. So we're focused. We're gonna try and get motions on the on the table very quickly. And then we can we can stay with the motion. So I would entertain a motion to to request that GBUS actually generates an appeal, makes an appeal against this decision. Or an appeal against DNR's decision for case the case numbers. Thank you. So we have that moved by Brianna? Do I have a second? Okay, so it's moved and seconded. So the motion in front of us is that GBUS or the service area would would actually appeal this decision. Would appeal the decision by DNA. Any comments from the board [415] Brian Burnett: right question on on the timing of the appeal and drafting of the appeal would would we today just issue a statement and a 200 fee to ask to consider the repeal motion. I think when was the deadline [440] Mike Edgington: for the appeal? Tuesday. Tuesday. So we have a little bit of time to do a bit more than that, but not much more. We've had to set the we'd have to set the parameters of any work we're doing in this meeting. So I have a question for staff if you've been able to research this. Is this even something we can do? Is this something we can spend taxpayer money on? No, right. So I think to me that makes it a fairly clear decision about whether we do the appeal or not. So when we get to a vote to note. Any other questions from the questions or comments or thoughts from the board. [487] Brian Burnett: Further further thoughts, and you know, I've I have to admit I'm not entirely opposed to seeing Ed Storm being able to exercise their right to use that easement to provide a loop system into the valley. So there are some potential trail wins for the for the valley and for future trail activity down through that part of the valley, whether it's the Danish Trail or the Virgin Creek Trail, there are opportunities I think that need to be considered. [570] Jennifer Wingard: Did you did you have a comment? Yeah so in light of our original letter of objection on this project in fact from a year ago, which might have more relevance for the agenda item number two. Now three I do wonder if it has any relevance on this or another way. Like is there anything we can have right to actually peel to that is there any room left for discussion on this proposal. [611] Mike Edgington: So is that a are you are you going to question I think there probably are other options, but at the moment the motion is whether we're not right. So we could and perhaps when we finish making that decision, you could you could open another motion. we [626] Jennifer Wingard: can [627] Mike Edgington: other item. [628] Jennifer Wingard: I was kind of hoping to hear from the original petitioner on this if he had any ideas given the legal decision. [637] Mike Edgington: Well I think we have that so the original agenda item one letter of support. we could potentially discuss that then. I think we'll get to that item. we're not actually doing the appeal ourselves, which is the that's what item number two was what we're currently considering. [659] Jennifer Wingard: I'm wondering if there are other aspects of this besides just legally whether or not because under the original discussion on Monday, I thought the petition on this was open to some other options. I'm just I'm curious about that. I don't have a motion in mind at this point. [677] Mike Edgington: Well I'm saying is perhaps that can come up later when when they're [680] spk9: I'm talking about this. Oh sorry, I thought we were talking about relevant. [685] Mike Edgington: Okay, yeah, yeah. Do you have any comments? I'm just open up to it. [689] Brice Wilbanks: I'm just happy thank you guys for taking it up and considering it. I think it's an important item for this community to look at. Especially looking at you know exploring options that GBOS and this committee can take in the future when other DNR posts come up like this. So I'd have the board wants to consider it from a legal perspective on a lawyer, but would be great if And you're looking at an issue, but it depends on how state define the first and whether or not G Boss represents a community of people in that account. I think it may it step in the right direction. So this body wants to consider it. That's fantastic. If not, you know it's keeping our toolbox document for anybody else who wishes to appeal this number as well today as well. [737] Mike Edgington: Any other comments from the from the community? Or board members. Did you have something, Brianna? [746] Brianna Sullivan: Thank you, Mike. Really quick, thank you for your comments, everyone. And I would say that I will not be supporting this motion. I don't feel that it is entirely within our scope as GBOS in providing services to our area to make this and it's also not possible in the way that we just said it, but doing something that they had planned and it's an easement decision by DNR. So those are my initial thoughts. [781] Mike Edgington: Okay, thank you. I'm not seeing any other [784] Kyle Kelley: other comments. So vote. Okay, my case. No, Ryan Burnett. No one guard Brianna Sullivan. No. Motion fails for zero four. Okay, thank you. [804] Mike Edgington: if we're not gonna do any other motions on this, we'll move on to items. Item number three. Determination of priority projects to proposed project anchorage. Again, do we have a supervisor who wants to leave this discussion? [820] Jennifer Wingard: Happy to do that since you and since I'm [824] Mike Edgington: just [825] Jennifer Wingard: gonna [826] Mike Edgington: have to agree with that. I wasn't agreeing with the mess, but [833] spk14: Okay, the openity. Please go ahead. [836] Jennifer Wingard: Okay. In a nutshell, I have mentioned several times throughout the course of the summer that I thought that we I wanted the community to be paying attention to project anchorage, and I understand that the way that they have set up the submission of potential projects to be completed if the tax passes. I understand two things about this. One, we're at a whole lot of if now. And two, that they set it up to be community members. And I make the case of land use, which again, I know everybody's heard already, that our situation in Guru might be a little different. I totally understand why they did not reach out to individual community councils not wanting to create kind of a turf or an anchor over people's pet projects. I think our considerations are a little different, and as always, we always have a concern about getting back some of what we're putting in to the general cost some return on into the general cost. So I apologize for not realizing earlier that maybe we could have consolidated this, and with at least looking at basically the frame on the top of the projects that have already been mostly voted by the community or thoroughly vetted by individual committees. And in light of that, I think there's an argument to be made that we could consider this, especially in our new with it with our whole collection of authorities, and also given that we're the ones responsible for spending the taxpayer money that does come to us. I think that there's an argument to be made that we could should submit what we see as being our community primaries. And so in light of that. I would propose and I would make a motion that we consider sorry excuse me I make a motion that we put forward our own package of projects for consideration to [970] Mike Edgington: okay thank you any other comments from the board wasn't a second thank you that's that's why we have two chairs in that case is there a second for discussion thank you no I was gonna hand in the chair and do it myself okay so we have we have the motion in front of us that's been seconded any discussion on the motion we obviously have not identified the specific projects this is the principle but so I do discuss it okay [1015] Jennifer Wingard: I've been trying to imagine exactly how to package this but I think one possibility that can be mine was to package this specifically as a Girdwood parks and remote well I don't want to use parks and record because it makes it seem like it falls up but I'm put it as a recreation package and I would like in accordance both with what LUC said and with the work that GHEC has already done I would personally like the Grid RV park to be at the top of that and then within that but within this idea of creating kind of a general recreation area specifically interest in creating a recreation area centralized here right around us and making room for making facilities for pickable Dog park, bathrooms, improvements on the skate park. I would like to see us turn this area into a centralized park district, but I believe that as part of creating as part of expanding Girtwood's potential as a park destination and recreation destination for anchorage that we could also easily include in the four trail with that. I don't know that the roads and drainage projects falls within the scope of project anchorage, but I understand it. So I wouldn't eliminate that on our own. I'd be interested in the board's understanding of project anchorage, but my understanding is that group and cemetery and roads and drainage projects doesn't necessarily fall within that. But that's just so thank you for the chance to that's I understand. [1111] Mike Edgington: Thank you. Any other comments from the board. Right. [1116] Brian Burnett: Thanks for that. That over here, Jen. I really appreciate your vision for around here. all of the places that we have available to us here in Anchorage. This is a excuse me, here in Girdwood for Girdwood and for Average to come to this is this is the best that we have to offer. I heard from from staff during the land use committee meeting some some concerns about as we as we continue to add more and more energy into our valley, more and more responsibilities to look after and upkeep the ability of our of our staff to keep up with what can be built into but I'm confident that we can figure out with with you know volunteer groups and whatever we've always been able to work out for what we have here in group. And in that, I would also I would like to suggest that the Glacier Creek suspension bridge as you know as part of a statewide project as far as in the traverse trail, the Alaska Wall Trail, I think is something that that would fit nicely into the package. Additionally the suspension bridge is going to be turned over to the forest service once it is complete, and that will reduce any impact for staff for managing. And the forest loop trail will will likely be able to be looked out for by the Gird World which in here. [1234] Jennifer Wingard: Thank you. Thank you for putting that out. I didn't mean to I didn't mean to not mention the suspension bridge, so thank you for putting that absolutely be part of it too. And I think that the long trail has a lot of potential to drive business and interest and I think the long trail is very exciting about it. So I'd be happy to support that in whatever way I also wanted to mention in terms of one of my motivations for doing this is I I'm a little uncomfortable with the way project anchorage kind of puts the owners for deciding what as a decision within project Anchorage. So at the very least, I think that there could be an argument made that G Boss putting a stamp on this does does give it, I would hope give the proposal. [1283] Mike Edgington: Thank you. So [1287] spk5: my observation is that before some of those things can happen, the master plan effort needs to take place. One of the items that has been discussed maybe internally and not really comprehensively is the potential for like development of pocket parks within the community, which if our community does grow substantially, you know, having all of our recreation right here isn't necessarily as ideal as it's been. Which, you know, is part of why we have the soccer field in a different location. So anyway, I just think that this is a pretty broad topic. And we've highlighted some specifics that are attractive, but I wouldn't want for us to be limited by scope right now in what could come up in that master planning effort. And I think it is a really important component to development of our next ph in recreation [1351] Kyle Kelley: Tailing off of what Margaret said there, I would suggest that we look at parks master planning efforts that would lead to the development of a Gird RV park, Gurwood Cemetery, cookable and all the recreational activities there. So that we know that we have community buy in on these improvements and we have a guiding document from the community that helps us as we go through these master planning. [1384] Jennifer Wingard: So two thoughts just by the top one is that I maybe I shouldn't have touch it like yeah I've imagined them here but I actually I think I just want to actually care where they are just so we don't hear but also maybe some great that they have their space so things like that. I'm not investing on on where these things are number one. But then I'm Kyle I'm not sure I understand your comments are you saying that we feel like we should have that before we put Any request on the forward? [1419] Kyle Kelley: I would probably say that we could go through each process and do a community outreach on each one and go through that process and then and at some point get the master planning done, but the master planning's been an item on our capital list for a long time, which was gonna lead us to developing individual projects out of that because that way we know where the community wants them and where they should be, and then we can put our time and energy and money into making sure we're putting it in the right location. So I do think master planning effort should start actually this fall. So we may be ahead of it, but I do think a plan should be in place so that we can follow that as a guideline for developing all these resources and services. [1469] Brian Burnett: Right question for staff, please. I'm not sure on what the what is the timeline on an Anchorage master plan for parks plan. Has there been a rewrite in that recently that you know of? And any communities that have specific park plans. [1490] Kyle Kelley: Well, there is a ton of individual park plans, you know, each park has its own planning and they didn't tend to do it you know by park parcel or park area. Okay, and so and then they do have a sort of overarching master planning document for parks and rec, but every time they get into it, and you the way you think about Guru is Girwood's like basically a neighborhood park in a way. We have two big large park parcels that we work with, one being Girwood Park here, and then soccer fields up there. And so planning those out. We have no planning or guiding documents right now for either. So in Anchorage, they have those and then they get into projects after that. [1537] Mike Edgington: Am I right to thinking that the Anchorage plan doesn't apply to go to an or it does have our own separate legal room. So there any I want to give the opportunity, Brianna, do you have anything to say comment? [1556] Brianna Sullivan: Yes. Really quickly after Carla and Margaret kind of thank you, Mike, wait everyone's comment. Thank you. Put it out there in a bigger picture. I feel like this idea is fine and it doesn't hurt to send something to Project Anchorage from GDOS. And maybe it can be more broad and not numbered, but have this parks and recreation feel because that is why we are such a destination for a lot of Anchorage and Muni and visitors. So to us all of these things fall in there, but project Anchorage's idea is that they choose, I think. But we could give these suggestions. So because all of them are have been going through so many years in financial work and approved approval, I think all of the ones that were said were fully valid. So if we want to have them listed but not numbered, would be comfortable with me, and then the title being parts and recreation featured. I think would appeal to the people of Anchorage, and if there's any favorite [1637] Mike Edgington: Thank you. Sorry, [1640] Kyle Kelley: I'll add to this, in I don't want to stall anything, and I do think the RV park is still a priority in the R V Park actually would I think have its own master planning process to get it established because we're essentially creating a new park parcel by taking over the ownership of that and then developing that parcel out it would have it have to have its own feasibility plan as a guiding document to lead designers into what they're gonna do and so we would have to go through a community process to say okay here's what here's where it's gonna be here's what it's gonna look like do you like this and then we get to something that is you know a understanding of what it's gonna be and then we send it to designers and we go through the whole design process so I do think that the R V park and then the master planning which leads to all these other small little things within our existing parks which is pickleball and dog park and things like that those two efforts could work side by side as we move forward to make it happen because because they that R V park will actually work independently from the rest of our park system because it'll be its own entity in the way it operates. So [1710] Mike Edgington: what I'd like to do is bring it back to the motion is in front of us which is a yes no on whether we do whether we pull it list not the details of the list. So we're talking a lot about the details of the list which is fine. Which I think presupposes we're gonna say yes to the whether we submit a list but let's go back to the to the motion any more comments on the whether we should or shouldn't produce a list. If not let's move to a vote on that [1735] Kyle Kelley: sure. Mike Edgitty Brian Burnett yes Jennifer Wingard yes Brianna Sullivan motion passes 4-0 right now we can get into the goal [1747] Mike Edgington: details of what we put on that and how we get to doing this by the end of by the end of Sunday. So I just have a couple of technical questions. Do we have obviously for the symmetry we have a full design everything's cost it out. and for the suspension bridge we do What was what are the status of the other project? The RV we have a an estimate of what feasibility study would cost. at least have step one. What about the other smaller projects? Has there been any work on that? [1779] Kyle Kelley: we've done some initial stuff, but no, we haven't got into it because we wanted to start that master planning [1785] Mike Edgington: process first before we go directly into that. Okay. And forest loop trail is there a clear cost for that. Yes. Okay, right, thank you. And I think I have a similar feeling to others that I think roads and drainage sits, they're important, but they probably sit outside of the of the scope of what project Anchorage at least has asked for. I do not think the symmetry sits outside of that, though. I think the what project Anchorage is looking for is a is a sensitive place, and the cemetery as conceptually designed, is not just a place for remains and memories. It's also a place of sort of where there's active there's active recreation, there's an amphitheater, there's various other things there as well. so I think that does fall with its sense of place. So I would suggest I think RV park at least feasibility and moving on to beyond that cemetery. I'm Forest Loop I do not think the suspension bridge is a such a great fit. I think it is conceptually, but it's got so much funding attached to it already. I don't think it's going to be very attractive to project Anchorage, but you're looking for sort of nice big shiny things of providing 7% of the funding or 3% of the funding or something to that project. It's already kind of got in existence. So my suggestion would be to to basically have the RV park symmetry park improvements, although I think we could argue that we should preempt this and go ahead anyway, doing a master plan independently of what we do for project Anchorage. And the forest loop trail. So that'll be my suggested list. And I'm not sure I have a priority between it. [1890] Jennifer Wingard: Did you are you including the force on that? [1893] Mike Edgington: Yeah, is it the so I would say Loc Symmetry. We should go ahead as a as a service area and start the master planning process, but put in a budget for implementation of the things which come out of that so they go so et cetera. And forest loop truck. So I would not include the master plan itself for parks. The suspension bridge and motion train. [1926] Jennifer Wingard: Can you talk a little bit could I find out a little bit about the where we are with the funding for the suspension bridge? I know you've sent it on it numerous times. It's just not in my brain, right at the moment. [1943] Kyle Kelley: I think by the time we this if this gets through the assembly and makes it onto a ballot and gets approved by the voters, I don't even know when it would actually go into effect. And we we're hoping to build next year. So the suspension bridge might be done by the time that this even makes becomes reality. So I wouldn't probably say it's not a priority through this project system or this idea concept. [1972] Mike Edgington: any other comments from supervisors. [1984] Brianna Sullivan: Yeah. Yeah, go ahead. Well basically what your suggestion for Mike and put that into emotion or [2000] Mike Edgington: Okay, so our list would be in no particular order would be RV park symmetry implementation of the park improvements that come out of the master plan and the forest loop trap. Thank you. Is there a second? Thank you. Jennifer. I just want to say I just want to say one quick point to come up. I think the I agree with the comments Carl made about how long this could take. My sense is that as currently structured, this is going to struggle to get through the assembly. The sales taxes at 3%, two thirds of that money goes into property tax relief, which is a generally a good idea to diversify our tax base. I think that's a good idea. I think the amount that goes going into property tax relief has definitely got a lot of criticism from from the assembly. The way that works in terms of regressiveness adds on top of the general regressiveness of a a sales tax. So I don't think that's going to be very successful, and I just don't see it being likely to pass in the time scale that's available where this would have to be a ballot question with all the details ironed out by January. So I think this is good is a good exercise to go through. I think we should play the game that you know the game that effectively we've been given by project Anchorage. I'm not sure I would rely on this funding coming through, even if we get selected by project anchorage, I wouldn't rely on this funding appearing within the next year or two. we get through the first phase. So that's just the context. you [2108] Jennifer Wingard: already said you wanted to say something. I appreciate your insights about the political realities of this, my feeling and I also appreciate the board willingness to. entertainment regardless and to take time up even if it's a exercise of utility we don't we don't know that for a fact and just in case it isn't but I also feel like it is a good exercise as you just stated of to just kind of think about our community priorities what our vision a lot of people to talk about kind of community our own community vision we're so busy fighting sometimes community vision we would be really nice to put forward our community vision even if this turns out to not be an environment that which fulce but given that I personally would like to see the RV part prioritized. Particularly because there's this there's a component of that which allows some relief to the winter housing crisis I'm increasingly convinced based on what I'm seeing kind of social that it's the winter when our housing crisis is the worst. [2178] spk5: That's what I have to say. I just wanted to observe that GBOS does have a capital improvements list and it does include parks and rec items. And so you know some of these have evolved since that has been updated. And maybe some of them are still emerging like when the property transfers then we can talk more concrete about the R V park I think rather than conceptually but we should probably like and make sure that that capital improvement list is reflecting some of the trails objectives that are being stated because I don't think that they are necessarily on as far as forestly trail we're still working forward on some projects as well with like the middle night did a rod and securing funding. So anyway when you look at that list again say Monday ish. I think it would be a good idea To make sure that what we're talking about now matches and is updated. [2241] Mike Edgington: Thank you. I'm trying to have one more thing I've got to say. Thank you, Jen, for bringing this to us. We should have been dealing with this. We did start the discussion and kind of dropped off. So thank you very much for bringing it in. I'm gonna go up to the I saw Crystal actually you typed a question. Do you want to just say it? Because we don't we can't see the chat. [2261] Krystal Hoke: Yep. I the question was can you share the screen of what the list is so that people online can see the list. Sorry. Yeah. Sorry, and so the pro the proposal that I had previously put together and did a presentation on it, land use included several of these items. We're saying that we don't have you guys are not proposing line item amounts that go with each of these items. Is that correct? [2296] Mike Edgington: I don't think that is correct, Crystal. I think what we would be doing is is giving an estimate in some cases we know what the cost is. In other cases we have we have some sense of an estimated cost. So we would put we would put an estimate, at least initial estimate, next to each of these. For the improvements around the park's master plan or coming out of the parts master plan, we may have just one number for the set of projects. But for the cemetery, we know for the RV park, I think we at least have a phase one estimate. And for Florence Luke, we have a number. So we wouldn't put it. I [2332] Krystal Hoke: just want to confirm is phase one estimate for the cemetery is 5 million, is that right? [2338] Mike Edgington: I believe so, yeah. I think that was the last number. Sounds [2342] Krystal Hoke: good. I guess I just want to be super transparent that it's likely that I'll be submitting a proposal that includes Girdwood Arts as well as recreation assets. Thanks. [2356] Mike Edgington: Thank you. Yeah, because anyone can anybody can submit to this list. We're just discussing what GBUS is going to do. Any other comments or discussions on this, I said, Jennifer? [2370] Jennifer Wingard: I kind of have a question about this, about what we were just stating about the kind of the need to have a project estimate in mind, because obviously that's gonna be a bit of a trick in three days for all of this. And I do appreciate kind of what Margaret. This is there is a slightly different aspect of this, which is the fact of having it be the city money. So for example, we don't have our V Park on our priority burner right now for the community because it's not our land. We're not gonna put it there until it's underneath our curve, right? So we we're we've been holding off on making that a budget priority because it doesn't make any sense to improve HLB land if they're not gonna transfer it to us. If the city wants to improve it, I'm fine so my personal feeling on the way, but also because of the way project anchor just set this up, they set it up as something that citizens would put forward ideas for. So I'm not sure they're expecting citizens to have budget estimates and all that. So I guess I just don't want to see this idea stall because we don't have all of the financial specifics. Okay, I don't think that would be required of the citizens. So we're just putting our voice forward just to kind of representing we hope as much as possible. This is what the group that's been interested in and looking for. [2452] Mike Edgington: I agree with you. I think we've just gone further than because of the body we are, we've gone further than other people would have gone with these particular projects. So since we have in most cases, that's what we should provide them. That's all I'm okay. Yeah, I agree, I don't think it's mandatory. We have a motion in front of us, which is an unordered list. Is it one, two, three, four items? From the board or community. Jennifer. [2480] Jennifer Wingard: I'd like to propose an amendment and see if it gets seconded or improved or whatever. I'd like to propose an amendment that we prioritize. [2490] Mike Edgington: Okay. Yes. Okay. Seconded. Okay. Any other before we do you want to discuss that any further? Or should we just vote on the amendment? Okay. [2510] Kyle Kelley: Okay. Mike Edge in. Yes. Brian Burnett? [2513] None: Yes. [2514] Kyle Kelley: General Wingard? [2515] None: Yes. [2516] Kyle Kelley: Brian. Yeah. That amendment to the main motion passes 4-0. [2525] Mike Edgington: Okay. I'm not going to make an amendment, but I'm going to offer it to anybody else if they're interested in making an amendment. Because it's so far down the path. I would suggest that go to symmetry is probably an item number two that we're going to prioritize. If anyone wishes to make that amendment, they can. If not, I'm not going to push it. Not hearing anyone do that. I'm sorry. [2553] Brianna Sullivan: I did a lot of work with the cemetery effort. [2562] Mike Edgington: Okay, so we have an amendment. Do I got a second? Is there a second? Yes. Yes. I've seconded that. Any further discussion on this item? [2578] spk16: Sorry. Question. [2579] Brian Burnett: Would getting it on this list preclude any future attempts to include this cemetery in some sort of bonding action or [2592] Mike Edgington: I don't I don't think so. I think this would be in all of the should be in all of the above. Unless you think otherwise. [2602] Kyle Kelley: I don't think so. Anchor's probably gonna be the same thing. They're gonna put projects on there they're probably gonna eventually bond for. So [2611] Mike Edgington: any further discussion? If not, then we will move to role call [2617] Kyle Kelley: okay. Mike [2617] Mike Edgington: Edg? Yes. [2619] Kyle Kelley: Prime Burnett. [2620] None: Yes. [2620] Kyle Kelley: Jennifer Wingard. [2622] None: Yes. [2622] Kyle Kelley: Rihanna Sullivan. [2625] None: Yeah. [2627] Kyle Kelley: Amendment passes 4-0. [2629] Mike Edgington: Okay. So we have in front of us a motion to put forward four projects. as a sort of package deal from Goodwood. From Goodwood. Goodwood RV park is one. Good symmetry is two, good park improvements, and or new trailer equal third. We can [2651] Kyle Kelley: move to a vote. Not seeing any further discussions, let's move to a vote. Mike Edgington. [2656] None: Yes. [2656] Kyle Kelley: Brian Burnett. [2657] None: Yes. [2657] Kyle Kelley: Jennifer Wingard? [2658] None: Yes. [2658] Kyle Kelley: Rihanna Sullivan. [2662] Mike Edgington: Main motion passes 4-0. Thank you. Thank you very much, Jennifer, for bringing this to that. I'm tempted to say that now means you have to do the work it would get. Oh thank [2673] spk9: you. [2678] Mike Edgington: If you're prepared to that, thank you so much. Okay. No more discussion on that title. We're now back to item number one. which is the which is for GBOS to provide a letter of support for a proposed appeal to DNR's decision on section line using for end star. you could take this [2709] spk9: so this [2715] Jennifer Wingard: support we appeal the section line is it's Yeah this came up this is all then under a pretty timeline and so this is another situation in which we've had to circumvent the way we normally like to do things but not because of us talking about just the nature of this process and so when I was first approached about this I mentioned that I thought it might fall to some extent under all business that it matches with the letter objection that we had already written so we've already taken a look at this project a little bit but the part that's different is the part about that what they needed to Margaret point it out on the front page here about the scope of the decision limiting to determine item is an acceptable secondary use of the access user we're a little bit caught once again in process and the ways in which process gives you often doesn't give us the same kind of what happens but this is them using their their users the guest so I think what I'd like to do for the sake of discussion here is make a motion that we support this opposition or well whether it's not it turns into a resolution or a letter of opposition make the motion that that we reiterate our objection based on aspects of that that are particular to the decision in this case our original letter of objection included things like objecting to the amount of public notice time and then obviously [2835] spk5: well I'm looking for a restatement of your motion Are you just I guess I can ask it as a question [2850] spk17: clearance. [2851] spk5: I'm sorry, I hope I'm not making it steamy. What say is TBOS is moving to write a letter determined in support of the appeal that the Raymond Yacobians [2870] spk10: are [2874] Mike Edgington: one thing I would point out is if we're writing a letter of support, it doesn't have to be submitted, I don't think at the same time as the appeal. You can do so as a support of the appeal. I'd like to give us a little bit more time. Okay. Potentially. Although I don't think it would hurt if we had it ready for London. Okay. [2903] spk5: Do we have a second? [2904] Mike Edgington: Oh sorry, we do not have a second. Thank you very much. I'm glad people are paying attention today. We have a second for the motion to write a letter in support of a potential appeal. I am not hearing a second. I think I will I would like to second it since nobody else has. So can I just formally hand over the chair to Brianna for about 30 seconds. I think so. Okay, thank you. Okay, so I have something. I would like to second the motion. [2948] Brianna Sullivan: All right, the motion has been seconded. Now we can open it up for discussion. Go ahead, I can't see any here. [2958] Mike Edgington: Yeah, I'll just say briefly. I'm really stuck on this because I think the We're as Jennifer said, we're stuck in this informally what's been approved is something that with one or two technical issues, especially the issue around the application claiming suddenly more hypercarbones. The very narrow question of is this a legal use of section line easement. I think we have to kind of is it's not I don't think in the best interest of the community necessarily. It's not the worst thing, but it's definitely not, I think, the best thing. and I'm not convinced that N Star has looked at alternatives. They've never told us that looked at alternatives. We've had no discussion around that. They haven't come and spoken to us. I still think some pressure is valuable. but I'm kind of still stuck on this very narrow question of whether the peel itself the appeal itself is the right way to do it, or whether we should just directly approach NSTAR and communicate with them directly about our objections. I'm just not sure. I'm really still stuck on this bit of both. So having said that, I think we should continue this discussion. So I'm gonna stop talking and see if anyone else wants to speak on it. [3037] Brianna Sullivan: Thank you, Mike. Anyone else next? [3043] Jennifer Wingard: Brendan's hand up. [3046] Brianna Sullivan: Oh, thanks, Jennifer. Any board members before Brendan? If not, I was just going to add that N Star intent, I believe, was to wait until the appeal process was finished. And go through DNR process before they come back and have any any changes or anything to update us with or updating that for the community. that is why an idea, perhaps from Mike's perspective that he said directly communicate with them, sorry. The route in front of us. Any other board members or then Brandon? [3089] Mike Edgington: Well I just like to say that we're not we don't we can do both. I mean we can both support the appeal and communicate directly with N Star. I think the latter is more likely to is probably the right formal process. but that doesn't preclude us from from supporting the appeal. I'm gonna keep the chair. You should keep the chair for the rest of the site. [3114] Brianna Sullivan: Okay, so Brendan, go ahead, please. [3118] spk3: Yeah, thanks very much. Can everybody hear me? Yes, yes. Okay, great. Yeah, thank you. Thanks. Yeah. Thank you for taking this up and on short notice to really appreciate it. And thank you for to Jennifer for spearheading bringing this up and I appreciate Mike's comments and I think that they're you know, from my perspective, I really like the comments that you're making and I would I think that there's value obviously for us as well as the just the community in general to some some sort of statement on the record, whether it's you know, I leave it to your better judgment, whether it's a resolution or a letter, that we as you know affected property owners and just in the community in general would be able to sort of point to and say, look, you know, GBOS reiterated its its position regarding reiterated its concerns regarding this. And I think that as Mike was pointing out, that even sort of aside from the you know the technical issue of is this an allowable use you know of the of the section line easement. And I think you know at least established by precedent, yes, at a general level it is at the sort of technical level of whether or not this proposal would damage the primary use which is trails and access and that issue that's definitely a big concern we have and I think that that and then I think that other more technical considerations as those we've raised in our letter that we submitted for this meeting are definitely germane here as as Mike also pointed out for example the problems with the application and I think just also the sort of general statements that pertain to the community's interests in terms of this not really being aligned with the vision that the community has set out for this area its potential to damage trails in there as well as damage the opportunities for future trails issues in there, which I think is a real possibility. I think one thing that we've all kind of learned through the P and Z process is that there are forces at work outside of Girdwood that have a much bigger say in these things than we do unfortunately in terms of our vision and I am definitely cons concerned about this leading to future activities that could potentially cut off future trail opportunities in here, for example, widespread housing development. but I guess I guess long story short, it would be really great to sort of hear maybe objections along the you know, some sort of form of statement along those lines that this is sort of not congruent with what the community is looking for. We that there, you know, there's we really haven't had engagement from N Star in the in the year since and we didn't have it at the beginning at the outset, which is really disappointing. And just some of the these other issues. I'm sorry, I'm a little scatter shot here. I'm trying to cover all the bases and I'm trying to be cognizant of your restricted time this afternoon, but so please feel free to follow up with questions if I'm being unclear, but I think that that would really help not just us and affected property owners, but just the community at large to have some sort of statement to that effect. And I think it sets a good tone for the record. Thank [3331] Brianna Sullivan: you. Thanks, Brendan. And it wasn't that scattered, I think with your email and letters together. Any other comment board members. [3352] Brian Burnett: I think I am not necessarily convinced that if this if N Star was allowed to use their easement as as it was intended, I don't know that it would necessarily damage the future use of this section of land and could quite possibly allow for future trail development in there, which would then more effectively protect the land there. If there was a developed trail head down there, if there was more developed and trails that oper that had an easement down there, I think that that would protect the land as well as anything, if not even protecting it better than having a couple of primitive trails down there that don't have that don't have an easement that they occupy. so I'm again I'm not convinced that that if N Star uses that easement that it is going to damage the future trail potential in that in that parcel [3437] Brianna Sullivan: thank you Brian [3444] spk12: yeah no further comment [3446] Jennifer Wingard: yeah okay I just want to kind of throw out an idea that and see what the board thinks I don't know how much precedence we have with this but I wonder if instead of having a resolution or a formal letter of objection if we could consider having basically a letter of interest or concern and just raise to both the approving agency and to NSTAR that we're interested in continued engagement and that could be anything from wanting to work with findings and benefits to this like Brian just mentioned you know actively asking for it basically not ashamed to mentioning the that we would like some clarification on high department impacts on some awareness of the conflicts with the our group of trails management plan group of trans master plan and groups plan even though I understand that this is not land that is specifically encompassed by that it was certainly we'll have impact on the community's intent for that land and then also raising the issue that raising the point that if we had more active community engagement there might be a way in future or even now to figure out some win wins around a potential reroute very similar to the one say for example that Brett mentioned in his proposal. [3542] Brianna Sullivan: Jennifer, would you be interested in changing your motion to what kind of morph into what you just said or discussion putting it out there? I [3553] Mike Edgington: was gonna suggest we do this as an amendment so we don't lose the original motion. Uh-huh. Okay. So I'll make proposals. So I suggest an amendment that we write a letter of not a letter of support for the it would not be a letter of support for the appeal, but we would write a letter of interest to NSTA second. Right. So seconded by Jennifer. So that's an amendment to our original motion. [3590] Brianna Sullivan: Okay. We have amendment and amendment to the original motion that obviously related, but kind of different. So anyone could vote differently, I suppose. [3604] Mike Edgington: Margaret, Margaret is [3606] Brianna Sullivan: coming. [3606] spk5: I have a question. Yeah, my question is if this is a letter to N Star, then this is perhaps not part of the need to get something in by sending. Right. Okay. [3625] Jennifer Wingard: Right, but the way the motion is currently standing or the way my idea was it's we're still subject to I think getting something in which the letter was gonna go to both agencies. Still the deadline is slurry, unless we board decides otherwise. [3644] spk10: I'm just looking for clarification. I think [3646] Mike Edgington: if we I think we pass this amendment, then we're talking about a letter, which is not part of the appeal process at all, not connected to the appeal process and separate. So I think you're correct it. Then it would not necessarily have the wouldn't have the same deadline. But we would still want to do it very soon. [3665] Brianna Sullivan: For all the clarification. Keep going if there's more in the room. [3670] Jennifer Wingard: So Brianna, there is a hand up from Brendan. [3674] Brianna Sullivan: Okay. Quickly, Brendan. Can't hear you yet, Brendan. [3685] spk3: Sorry, I dropped my hand instead of dropping the mic. It's only been four [3692] Mike Edgington: years, Brenda. [3693] spk3: Yeah, I know. No, I thank you. Thanks for the brief. I do think I did want to address the trails issue and I appreciate the different perspectives on that. I do just want to reinforce that I think we need to be careful about unknown here. And I think we do have some knowns here, which is that this would damage existing trails that we know about. And I think we have the known that like DNR does not seem to really understand trails in this their decision. And we have the known that you know future development in this area could very well ruin all trail opportunities there. And I definitely don't want to bank on you know possible the possibilities for this to assist with trails, for example. Potentially even at the expense of the broader area. I don't want that to be sort of a hope that we bank on when it's an unknown and we know other things definitely damage trails that this would that this would entail damage to trails. That being said, I do appreciate GBOS wanting to continue to engage on this in whatever way they can, especially engaging N Star on the issue of alternative routing. Or even DNR on alternative routing. I think that that that was a great component of what Bryce brought up at land use. I would hope that there could be some sort of statement and some capacity about GBOS, you know, not seeing this as congruent with what we've laid out in the our plans and also not being happy with the engagement and not being happy with you know certain aspects of the application. I think that those are probably you know those are probably well to my mind they're acceptable. I don't I don't know about to your mind. But yeah, I just reiterate that again. And anything that as an appellant here, anything that I can append to the appeal is also obviously helpful. So if in the end that ones up only ends up being the land use approved resolution, so be it. But yeah, just wanted to throw that out there as well, just as a sort of thing for the future that I might be approaching staff for, I suppose. Thank you. [3840] Brianna Sullivan: Thank you, Brendan. Any other comments. [3848] spk13: There are no more comments. [3851] Brian Burnett: I would also just like to state that you know, as as we're considering alternate routes, eventually this project is going to get in in someone's backyard. There is there's no question there will be somebody's backyard is gonna be impacted by this. The question is who's [3876] Mike Edgington: I did a ball for the [3878] spk11: move to a vote. [3879] Mike Edgington: Sorry, I did that one's other comment as well, which isn't it's not it's related to this. It's not directly on the motion, but this does this whole this whole experience has brought up the question of the other section line easements throughout the that in principle pretty much any agency or individual if they have a justification. can drive a fairly significant swap through many parts of the valley it's just something we should be aware of and if we're if we're looking at preserving areas more than they are at the moment is section line vacation is something we should perhaps consider at some point in the future for some areas that was all otherwise let's go to the vote [3925] Brianna Sullivan: okay thank you Mike and I really fast would like to add that this experience also then would set a precedent with whichever way we act or just learn from it that the history and the future of land easements in the state of Alaska and utilities but also that people in our community would be engaged and have the right and ability to appeal okay I'll ask for roll call vote or the [3958] Jennifer Wingard: clarification [3960] Mike Edgington: yeah the clarification is this is an amendment to write a letter expressing our disagreement with talking to N star and expressing our disagreement with our concerns about let's put it that way not a direct support of the appeal that's what the amendment says the main motion is a direct support of the appeal that if this amendment passes then it would be replaced by a letter to N star showing our concerns with the project okay not be a [4000] Kyle Kelley: okay so this isn't a main main [4002] Mike Edgington: this isn't an amendment to the main motion this is the amendment to the main motion okay which changes the changes main motion okay [4010] Jennifer Wingard: is it sorry process wise process motion isn't this the best way to do it or should we just [4018] Mike Edgington: I guess that's the otherwise we'd have to vote down to the first one. This way at least what we this vote is effectively decided what we do and then we say yes or no to the whole thoughts take it a different way we're about to vote on amendments if we say yes to the amendment then the only thing we have in front of us is to write the letter to N star expressing our concerns if we vote no to this amendment then we have a second vote of deciding whether to write a letter of support for the appeal or not [4062] Kyle Kelley: okay Brianna you ready I think so all right start with Brianna Sullivan No Mike Edgington yes Brian Bernett no Jennifer Wingard yes motion two two motion fails okay back to the main motion it we'll state that again for the record no problem recording [4098] spk5: our original motion was the GBOS supports writing a letter of GBOS will write a letter of support for the appeal by the remote copy [4111] Kyle Kelley: Okay so back to the main motion and Brianna Sullivan No Mike Edgington Yes Brian Burnett noingar [4129] Mike Edgington: yes vote is two two motion fails I thought that was a very good very good discussion. [4144] Brianna Sullivan: Would you like to chair back, Mike? [4145] Mike Edgington: Yeah, okay. Yep. Great. Thank you, [4149] Brianna Sullivan: everyone for dealing with me while I share. [4155] spk5: staff I'm noting that you have two items on the agenda today that haven't gone exactly as was recommended by land use. And so I just want to remind you that there's a process for handling that. [4169] Mike Edgington: Yeah, I think that's a co-chair's responsibility, so we will do that. [4172] spk5: Okay. [4173] Mike Edgington: We do not I don't think we have time to did the yes we have two items out three, yes, sorry, understood. public comment person offering public comment mistake the full name and address. Public comment is limited to three minutes per person. Must be on subjects not listed on the agenda. Does anyone want to make a public comment? I'm not seeing any. say one thing before we move to an adjournment. It's actually a comment which Kyle made to me earlier today. There is a I mentioned in the work sessions this is about Monday's meeting. I mentioned in the work sessions that I'd bring forward an amendment for the budget and they are in the meeting packet, so it might be worthwhile just looking at those and checking out in the meeting packet for Monday. we will now move on to although [4226] spk5: I haven't gotten it compiled yet. There will be [4229] Mike Edgington: packet. [4230] spk5: So there were some technical problems. When revised packet comes out, that will be included. [4237] Mike Edgington: Thank you. There were problems with the website today, weren't they? That's the reason. Okay, we'll now move on to a journal. Thank you. Thank you very much, everybody.