[2583] Jennifer Wingard: I was I'm surprised because I we got a lot of feedback about that too this week, but we have as Bianca said some official things that are some on the record comments about that, and we will move on. Okay so old business. I believe our first item of old business now is the star project. So this is Sterling and Story, you could please introduce yourself and I'm Sterling start. [2613] spk1: We also have Zach and So I hear some of your comments before on short time frames for development products and Girdwood. First thing I'd like to say is that if contact the GBOS, I would have done it much sooner than this. April of this year, there's a time period for developing content for it. DNR or a land use or sorry use authorization for existing section one which crosses from a reveal over to where eventually we will tie in this project and create drive. And so My main goal with being here, I wanted to show up. I wanted to listen to your concerns as a community. I realized that August 14th is a relatively quick turnaround time for that project. It's new to you, most likely. And I wanted to answer any questions you might have with that. There are a number of different permitting actions that still need to take place before this does proceed. Or work within Ruin Drive will need an OA utility permit. And as far as use within the section line, easement that is authorized by the state of Alaska E and R. Prior to this project, I'm not aware of any that actually did require a public use period. So this is the first for me, too. I realized that a 14 day period seems pretty limited. Submitting this back in April may time frame. Unfortunately, this is where we're at now. And like I said before, I don't have to answer any questions. [2756] Brianna Sullivan: Yes, starling. So just stay there or sit there, your voice can tell you. I have several questions, but first start with the information that this came up in April. So why would it come up in April? And then after that, how many notices did you send to neighbors? Yeah, okay. [2774] spk1: To neighbors now [2777] Brianna Sullivan: or residents or property owners on Oregon Creek Drive. [2780] spk1: Correct. We hadn't sent any out. This is the first project where use authorization such as this through through DNR. Typically we apply for it we just issue the letter of authorization. There's no public comment required in order to achieve that. we also would be using planes utility us there's no review process currently with the MOA for said use so it had not been a requirement and so that's the first for us as well for public [2819] Brianna Sullivan: but some people to continue some people didn't receive it like in the main [2825] spk1: recent yes and that was through the DMR process okay and so this is a new process that they're implementing this year [2835] Brianna Sullivan: okay I contacted a few of the people property owners and not many had received anything okay don't know if it was just on the drive only or something beyond what [2848] spk1: DNR require I'm not sure which so that would be a question for DNR [2858] Jennifer Wingard: questions yeah I do it want okay Amanda you have a question [2866] spk11: I have a few questions also but probably one of Brianna's will be this I was wondering what is the purpose and benefit of additional gas line of the additional gas line and why now [2882] spk1: the main answer to that question is reliability so currently transmission system so transmission is provided by Alaska Pipeline company unless it's a sister company that is our the transmission system extends to Ruandrive. Which are where a regulator is located and draws down high pressure transmission gas into distribution pressure. That one feed serves all of Girdwood through Aliaska through the Alliaska highway. And so the risk that that has is that if there is a damage to that system, it brings gas or it brings down service to every single every single user of natural gas down system. And so the main this project is to reinforce that with what we call a two IP. It will add a feed on the back side of the system so that if there is a damage to occur, service will be lost to other users. Does that answer your question? [2962] spk11: Yes, thank you. I see it's on the screen too. I didn't realize that before. So thank you for just repeating it. [2971] Jennifer Wingard: And did you have more questions, C mean I have one you might ask it? this doesn't involve any wetlands. [2983] spk1: There are more wetlands adjacent to the area near glacier creek as a part of our install we're required to be a certain amount of footage offset. I think it's 200 feet either side of the embankment of glacier creek. And so essentially you will boar underneath well and so there's no surface disturbance to [3009] Jennifer Wingard: you like an HBD underneath the creek [3013] spk1: glacier creek and burden creek where it crosses, yes, [3016] Jennifer Wingard: and [3017] spk1: sorry, California Creek within Green Drive [3021] Jennifer Wingard: has. You need title 16 permit or something to this with the stream bag or underneath the string bed? [3031] spk1: We don't for boring subsurface underneath the stream bed, we've in practice but given a blanket authorization. It's a non-conflicting use with fishing game. [3047] Jennifer Wingard: I think you're gonna use a money to do that. Is there any method in there? There's a natural source drilling, I guess and Kevin that be the creep. I guess it'd be interesting to know how deep you're gonna be well specifics on that as well. I guess when going back to my original question. using the MOA wetlands map or using the [3076] spk1: There's a number of different wetlands maps available. So the MOA has and welding map or so look at the fishing wildlife service wetland map or yes, both of those sources are overviewed as a part of our project review process. [3092] Jennifer Wingard: Internally the core correct so along your along your train itself. That has all been delighted and [3105] spk1: we've used those sources to basis [3111] Jennifer Wingard: basically, right? It has been we have no [3125] Brianna Sullivan: I had a question regarding long term and the news recently about Alaska's potential shortage of natural gas and importing it. So what would the impact speed for Gardwood and cooking the gas? [3140] spk1: that's a question that kind of falls out of the scope of what I'm preparing responsible to that. It's a good question. One that a number of people that our company are working on, but I'm just not the person to ask regarding future long term this [3158] Brianna Sullivan: and then Margaret may ask you scroll to one of the maps. U that shows the screen [3164] spk4: sure if you don't mind I just wanted to explain to people what this page is this is a list of questions that Mike Edgington had prepared and that we received answers to so just so that people understand what the purpose of that page is and yes I will scroll down it is in the packet it's online if they're all gone it looks like there might still be one I have one here in front of me too if somebody wants [3200] spk1: it. It's nodding or was one of the permits that we also need for this project is department of environmental conservation that has been ordered through the third party that third party will inspections and back to ensure that we're in compliance with any sort of these regulation that is is stabilization of any surface of service soils so it's part of the project we will be obligated to reseed and stabilize the area [3249] Brianna Sullivan: And then one change. Okay. Thank you. Well, it's been brought up that maybe because this is being so sudden to Girdwood, there might be a better time and planning to do this, like coinciding with second access road or a second bridge or an emergency access road that is actually in some of our hands from years and years ago to have an access road over there. And then also that when has the culvert replaced. If this project does one when they're just done together, it just seems like there's better use of all the resources, and maybe like does it have to be a straight line? And I know that it's not everything here is to scale, but that might not be the exact line of something future to utilize both at the same time. [3305] spk1: It's a good question. So my consent over the current from 2011 the original outside plan for future road development. Just in a brief review of that, there's a number of permitted issues that are complicated that project, but it does extend to an area where we don't currently have distribution. So the main goal is to fire to distribute the edges or distribution facilities together. So unfortunately just won't accomplish that goal and not in the time frame that we would need it to happen. [3349] Brianna Sullivan: I think so. So I just turned at the time frame that things want to happen. We have a since April, there's a timeline that all needs to be done because well it's alright, [3364] spk25: why is it need to be done? That's the needs be done by me now. [3371] spk1: Star is identified the system as one that's susceptible to damages that would cause losses to a number of customers. And in order to ensure that reliability is something that could be constructed. Excuse me. [3400] Jennifer Wingard: Okay. I do have people with hands raised and waiting. [3406] Brianna Sullivan: And one more that I like to address while the map is up about the wetlands versus the each access side so the application that was mentioned which vehicles would be driving over. You get to the middle. I will with the horizontal drilling with the driving over the extent of [3429] spk1: the so in wetland areas we're required through nationwide specific to your question for before installation of natural gas facilities within wetlands is covered by nationwide permit well. there's a number of conditions within that very welcome to those conditions is that we use construction maps, preserve the top layer vegetation to the best of our ability, record so use of maths would likely occur in areas of wetlands. As far as boring you would have the drill site on one side of the creek and an exit site on the other. Typically you would have the four ring on one side that would screen and pull through the pipe. the drill to the other. So you drill one way, attach to the pipe, and then pull it back through to tie in on the opposite side. [3497] Jennifer Wingard: Thank you. So I have a quick question about I believe you said the DNR this is a new process for DNR. They haven't normally had a public comment period [3508] spk42: is that correct? For use of section [3511] spk1: specifically. Section line easements have been utilized for transportation, transportation infrastructure prior to this it was just a submittal notification to DNR. And then they would issue a letter or a letter of authorization that would prevent that project to proceed. [3535] Jennifer Wingard: So maybe you wouldn't know the answer to this question, but I'm just curious what in what way DNR is planning on utilizing the public comments like is are the is the are the public comments going to make any difference in doing do you know or is this more like making sure the community is this more by the way this is what's happening kind of notes. [3557] spk1: That would be a better question for DNR. I think their public notice they do have some guidelines for that typically I guess better to ask DNR specifically they look for conflicting uses so if there was some sort of competing project or use that conflict with star's use of that existing section that's what they would DNR would be a session right. [3590] Jennifer Wingard: Okay and one other question I believe I heard you say that there is a be an effort to preserve the native vegetation as much as possible. And also you've got a number of wetland requirements right that you have to meet Can you can you tell me who is is it DNR that's responsible for making sure you guys adhere to that or is there another chairs? Okay, army corporate chairs correct. Right. Okay. Okay. Do you want to let some people go? Yes. Okay, let me take a comment or two from the room. Chief Westin is this about this subject. Okay, [3632] spk33: I'm gonna say that's keep questions. [3635] spk4: Yes, Michelle, could you come forward? There's a microphone right here, too. I just want to make sure that people online can hear us. [3646] Michelle Weston: obviously insert to the current and also shirt this year in spring. I found out about this on social media, right? A couple days ago. So that's probably not the best way to require curve to sign it. That's just my first opinion. Is a section line easement, so are other utilities could they also use them, yes? what is the end state of the easement? Is it gonna be a road or trail? Or what is the end state? What does it look like in its end state? [3683] spk1: I can't speak to other uses or other projects after SR is complete with this work. We'll compile with our private obligations to restore it to the condition required to by the permit. And as far as other public uses that would be for other public utilities or safe. [3712] Michelle Weston: Or is it just in a change its state? What is the end state look like? Obviously, under the creed still agree, but in the area that you prefer to all that. What does that look like in state wise? 20 foot small course. [3729] spk1: Yes, the 20 foot clearing will occur. And re-fegeted with the current as far as access. So the we do need three or seven to conduct. I think currently it's every four years we get a conduct leak survey. That is sometimes a mixture of pedestrian access or TV access. I don't know which we would do for this project. [3753] Michelle Weston: Right. So that's that's where I was wondering where like what the state looks like. So is there a couple more questions? Obviously it's a bit of a logging operation for some of it, right? So who's doing that and where is it? What happens to that temperature? [3770] spk1: Zach may be a better person to ask he's on the phone. [3774] spk12: Here. Yeah, so great winter reservist will do the clearing for us. We'll probably clear a 15 foot wide swath through there. Maybe up to 20. We'll minimize it as we can and we'll mulch and chip it on site and lay that on the ground for the time being. Just just preserve the ground as much as we can. reseed, you know, for the permit. And likely, you know, kind of going back on your first first question there. When we leak survey that every four years, we'll you know most likely be on foot. Possibly depending on how firm the ground is, but I got a feeling it's gonna be on foot, or possibly in the winter, once it's firmed up some snow machine, but it's a short enough distance. We it's likely gonna be on foot. [3836] Michelle Weston: So it would end state would look something like the distribution line that runs parallel to LS highlight. [3844] spk12: Similar to similar to not as yeah usually what happens here is we clear it, reseed it, and then things start growing like alders and stuff like that, and that kind of just is what it is. Whether people start using it as a trail or not, I don't know, but yeah [3869] Michelle Weston: and then one final question. There be like a step down vault or facility or wherever at Virgin Creek where you have a step down step down anywhere because it had a step no included in this project. So there won't be any other thing at Virgin Creek and then sign the existing guest line. [3892] spk12: Yeah, everything will be underground. [3897] Jennifer Wingard: Okay, so we dive into more public comments. I just want to remind people we're gonna try to keep things to three minutes, and the other thing given the level of interest that I'm seeing already on this subject. It'll help if you do agree with something that has already been said, please feel free, of course, to say that, but we don't need to fully restate. So we're gonna try to keep our comments to things that have not been stated before, and I'm gonna take one more comment from the room and then take some online. So [3930] spk28: sure. [3930] Jennifer Wingard: Sorry, can you come forward so everybody can hear you? That would be great. And state your name. [3935] spk9: Yeah, sure. Yeah, I prefer some comments with questions in it. My name's Brendan Raven D Cobian. I live at 164 Virgin Creek Road. This proposal would not only run the public open space lands directly in front of my house, but also through an easement on my property. I'm 100% opposed to this for a lot of reasons. I'm also asking GBOS to write a letter of objection to this proposal. The first issue regards something that's been talked about a bit, which is the essentially zero outreach and engagement with affected property owners, business owners, and the community. You know, we talked on the phone before, and you told me that this basically you guys drop the ball on this, which doesn't really seem congruent with the way that it's being talked about today. And regardless of how things were done or not done with mining land and water in the past, there's really no reason not to be a good neighbor and make contact with people in a timely manner. You know, only a handful of adjacent property owners were notified about a week ago with a common deadline 10 days later. the first anyone as far as I know in the community heard about this. And starts only here tonight because we alerted GBOS. I think all that's sorry, it's ridiculous. Like so my first question, I guess to Ed Star would be, will you withdraw this proposal until you have time to achieve can satisfactorily address all concerns from the community? my second comment that I'd make is about the possibility that NSR either doesn't really know or doesn't really care about the importance of the existing character of this land and how it would negative this proposal negatively impact it. The areas in open space, which has the most restrictive zoning possible to preserve its undisturbed natural character, it's highly valued first and foremost for that, for its use as recreation for the ecosystem. It's a crucial part of the view shed, at least for me and perhaps other property owners. We didn't build our own basic towards designated open space to look at a clear cut through it. This proposal would severely degrade all of that, including one of our community's most prized trails. And also, as one of the supervisors noted earlier, I mean it has to be considered here for something that's basically, as far as all evidence shows, an unsustainable resource future for natural gas and self-central. So I guess my second question is how are you going to avoid all those significant impacts and what assurances can you provide to the community about that? And the third thing I'll mention is just some more questions about technical aspects. The proposal says you'll cross urgent glacier creeks, which is not the case because Virgin Creek isn't in the alignment. there's no mention of California Creek in the proposal, but it is in the alignment, both of which are inadmish streams. People actively fish on California Creek near the eastment. the application says you're gonna stay in the uplands, which would basically probably obliterate the lower Virgin Creek Trail experience. building on the side of the bench or the lowlands is not what you proposed. And even if it weren't, I don't see how you could do this on the side of the bench or in the lowlands, which may have wetlands, which are unclassified as of yet. would obviously hugely impact property owner view sheds and also run straight through a boulder field. That probably extends many feet subsurface. I know it did on my property, just to the just to the east. So my third question is how have you guys accounted for all of this? And finally, just for folks on the radio, please make public comment opposing this. Google ADL 234206 to find the public notice. Comments are due currently at the end of July 20. You can find the email information on there, but it's an email comments in opposition to yanic.calvez at Alaska.gov as Y A N N N I C K dot C A L B E Z at Alaska.gov. [4174] spk47: Any response? [4177] spk1: Yes, and I can do my listing your buttons off one of those. Sure. So the best answer those [4185] spk9: the first one is whether you will withdraw the proposal, at least temporarily, and so you've ensure that you can address all the concerns of the property owners. [4196] spk1: So we're going to follow the process. Process provided by DNR. We do have the permits in the England project will be construct. [4216] spk9: So I'll think that the second question is how are you going to avoid period negative impacts and what shorts this can you provide about them all negative impacts [4227] spk1: that I mentioned. There's a number of [4235] spk9: sure this is open space or it's understood characters for recreation you should up and get those sort of people through people who are basically right next to this open space as you meant yeah and as you mentioned also actually this section easement is actually for access not for utilities that's a secondary that's the secondary usage recreation access is a considered access in this probably recreation [4273] spk1: so I guess that's that's that's certainly a comment that you're able to make through the public comment process as far as transportation uses and specifically public utilities being considered a favor that's something that historically has been allowed to use within a special needs so [4300] spk9: I know my third question but I guess I'm gonna comment for that's also getting started basically sending that your question all possible responsibility what people are saying here to somebody else as [4310] spk1: far as constructing the project or not and starting us to construct the project as far as the state to your concerns that's why I'm here and I'm to the best of our ability, I'll address any specific concerns that you have. And that's what I can do. Answering is about [4335] spk9: the best my belief right now. So all right, I'll take that as you can do that. And I guess the third question is how you account for all the second function like the fact that this run it on top of the bench, you're gonna destroy a trail. I mean the only people I've seen out there but surveyors. I mean there's not any technical analysis that's at all like on the ground. [4363] spk1: Yes, we have the second discussion issue that you're bringing up a very good question as far as constructability. better able to answer that question, but typically the way our permanents work is that we're only able to construct in the alignment that we apply for. And so if there is any future change to that alignment for whatever reason, whether it be to non-constructability, conflicting use, whatever that is, we wouldn't need to reapply through the permiting process. And as far I think you asked another question about California create, right and the reason that's not included in the specific application is because this is just for use of the section line these move. California creeps is less of the section windings and okay right away. And so it would be a part of that permiting process. [4419] Jennifer Wingard: Okay, if I may like to move on to some other comments. I'm gonna take two of the people online. Start with Mitch, thinking you've been very patient. And leave your hand up for a while. [4434] Mitch Roth: Thank you, can you hear me okay? Yes, Yeah, thank you. Mitch Roth. I live at one thirty nine Sto Drive. And well, I have a I have a question first of all, but then I would also like to make some comments. So should I try to do that all in one interaction or will it be a comment period separately later? [4463] Jennifer Wingard: I think if you made your comments for some follow up with the questions. Will that work? [4471] Mitch Roth: Well I need information from the question because [4474] spk21: the questions [4477] Mitch Roth: it's kind of like you know, this train is already leaving the station and I'm running down the platform trying to get on it to figure out where we're going. So yes, the question is normally in the case of public utilities construction that involves the taking of public land for a public utility purpose, there would be some kind of review process that considers very all various alternatives to meet the purpose of the project. and I haven't heard anything like that in this project. What I'm hearing is that M Star wants to build this pipeline, and they have through the DNR process the right to do it. So my question is really what kind of process was there any sort of permitting process or regulatory process which addressed the need for this pipeline and considered various other alternatives, including no pipeline as well as perhaps reroute if there's some actual need for the pipeline. And so what sort of process occurred that can justify the destruction of a mile of forest land to build basically a technology that is for a dying industry and is unsustainable. that's what I'd like to hear. I'm used to working with electric utilities where they have to demonstrate the need for the project, and then you make a determination of what's in the best public interest, and if it involves the destruction of natural habitat because it's important enough that we need to do it, that's the way it is, but haven't heard anything like that here. I've just heard that DNR will allow this because it's an allowed usage, and so that's my question. [4612] spk1: So the difference between other projects which may be subject to similar regulatory process where you can find alternatives investigate difference between that and this project is this section is an existing right within reserved state reserved transportation or where public utilities and the rate for use through whatever through whatever the permiting process DNR would require. This is the process that DNR does require as far as investigating alternatives. There are no economic alternatives that could be constructed that would result in the project's success. There's no distribution system where that would connect to that we can die. This is the best alternative that we could find. Any other alternative would actually more than smile that you mentioned. It is the route where there are existing rates available for and started to use. [4715] Mitch Roth: Yeah, yeah thank you. Okay, so the follow-up is really the bigger picture of the front page article in last Sunday's, not yesterday, but the week before was the headline rail belt utilities way options ahead of cook inlet natural gas shortage. And it was a very good, probably everybody here is aware of this, and if particularly if you've lived here since 2010, you're aware of that this is not a new issue. But it also contained a number of basically falsehoods, which the natural gas industry continues to promote. And the one that's relevant here is that later on in the article it said that M Star has no easy alternative to replace L and G for home heating. Well, this is completely false because using natural gas for home heating is about the least efficient way that you can do home heating, and it's a big waste of natural gas. And the reason that's false is because technology such as heat pump provide heat much more efficiently than burning natural gas. And So but this has been the prevailing idea that we've got a crisis with natural gas shortage, we have to find more natural gas. We can only import it. Instead we should be planning for conserving the natural gas we have, extending it as long as we can and moving away from natural gas entirely. And therefore any investment in expanding the distribution and building the infrastructure for natural gas is really just money away because we should be working at ways to use the gas more efficiently and conserve it. So as a result of that, I'm completely opposed to any pipeline. And that would be far more economic than destroying a mile of forest land and habitat that will never get back. And what we'll eventually end up with is an empty gas pipeline beneath a destroyed section line. So the long range implications are really horrible. And I would urge the aside from all the objections to the process but at some point we have to put a stop to this development that's non-sustainable. And this is a good point, and I would urge the board of supervisors to file a resolution in opposition to this project on any one of the multiple grounds that people have raised. or at least slow it down and stop it until people have a chance to understand what's going on here. So that's my comment. Thank you very much. [4907] Michelle Weston: I merely had a question which was how much is this project expected to cost? Okay. I mean it seems like this would be a very expensive project. And I'm having a hard time understanding how it came out of nowhere in April. I feel like we had conversations where we were told that our utilities in Girdwood were just fine and that we could handle adding more homes, et cetera. And now this looks like we need this huge reinforcement is necessary all of a sudden to the extent that it needs to happen this summer. So it just and then and then there's no budget to go with it. So that's just another question mark as to who's who's footing the bill. Is this will be covered by an N star bond. [4963] spk1: Yeah, N star is capitalizing the project. [4968] spk22: Okay, thank you. So the this project [4976] Jennifer Wingard: sorry, sorry, excuse me. I think we have a response. Sorry, Zach. Please go ahead. [4982] spk12: Yeah, so the we've been looking at this project for a long time. This goes back to when QAP was, I believe it was QAP was reworking out highway. And they hit that six inch line. It wasn't fully severed. It was partially severed, I believe the at that time we lost a handful of customers and the hotel at the end of the way. So you know, with expansion down the line and increased load on the system. you get to a point where even if you get a partially severed line or you get a fully severed line, you're you're talking days and days and days of rewrites. That our service folks would have to come out and do, and if it happens when it's cold out, for whatever reason, then you're talking about houses freezing up before we can even get to them, you know, repair it and rewind everyone. So that we've been eyeing the project for a while. It's gotten to the point where we just think it needs to be done to reinforce the system and put a two-way loop in there. That's where that's kind of where this has come to a head. [5061] Jennifer Wingard: Thank you. Let me take another comment from the room how about right there. I'm sorry, I don't know your name here. [5068] spk1: Oh my goodness, Christy's sort of 1056 turn on my road, which I appreciate you got top round times, but we're the last section line goes through, so I'm learning a lot about section lines, our decisions and things to speak. I was going to ask how much you're also because it sounds quite expensive to me. I can probably ask lots of questions about the exact menu use or why it has to be a circle. It sounds like a very you know narrow and somewhat deeper ditch. So that's quite concerned, yes, right. This isn't really commonly used recreational area. And then because my back looks on it's like it's water and it's not a small number of people. it's actually quite impactful to the community. Although it's appears just like I mean in other places section line means that's not that big deal for the state or show. I guess I'm encouraging what listen if you know section line was like in sure you don't proof that on top of one. And then it's for customer dependents for customer for all since you got it. I can certainly appreciate what everyone's saying about having a loop feed and the reasons that could be valuable. But I also say it's a customer at the end of the line, he's probably most likely to stop for an outage. I'd be okay to stop grade an outage for this project that's being proposed, right? But as my point out, if we're just talking about capitalizing this process safety rate pairs as customer rate pair, I'd be okay about paying for this project. And I understand the consequences if it doesn't occur and I'm perfectly willing to look for those. I was really surprised that part only a few of us were notified, right? Like I got the slider from saying that kind of scene everyone go to get a letter and if I don't like 10 minutes for a came here. I may be one of like three people that got a letter, right? So I can appreciate the situation that stars in that you know, perhaps they do this a lot, it's usually not too bad. Maybe those section lines are kind of complacent that people aren't very concerned about. It's really ways people are concerned about. And so I would echo in my street QB's request the GPO's right a lot of proposition we see for the moment. It doesn't sound mean like there's any reason it has to occur by August. I mean, I understand this jeopardy. What I also understand is that's been the same jeopardy for the entire time we've got gas service. So if it's this huge public safety concern, I wouldn't expect that I would you know in a lot of speed spots very hazardous situation that we must rectify. It's sort of the first time I've ever heard of it, but maybe I just didn't have tension. but it doesn't sound me like a crisis. And so I'd say. I don't consider a crisis that everyone else does. I would have said a lot of opposition. We can perhaps better answer some questions and contemplate like the best way to do the project. Maybe it doesn't need to be a 20 foot wine swap. It's really 20 feet. I said why does it have to be 20 feet? They said, Well, we'll have to go fix our survey. That's probably not a good way to survey their valley, and a fall road is probably a worse way. So if we're line that requires the trench two feet wide and four feet deep, that we're gonna survey it foot. Maybe there's some construction reason that requires 20 feet of line, but I'm not quite sure I see it right. I think I said it's a four inch diameter's type. I don't know that I would ever be really in favor of it, but I certainly wouldn't be nearly as close if somebody who wasn't saying we're gonna clear cut a 20 foot wide swap, and we're gonna maintain that forever. That's kind of my feedback. [5323] spk12: So we we're probably looking at 15 feet wide is what we would clear if we could get away with it. And that's dig in the trench. That's stacking the spoil pile next to it, and that's fusing, having room to fuse a pipe. Alongside that and get equipment in there. [5352] spk39: Oh we've got so many. [5354] Jennifer Wingard: Oh, sorry, did you have a response? [5357] spk1: Specific response, but to brand sorry, but the brand mic specifically. I know this is right in the second. That's what I had apologize to the phone, Brenda. I should have contacted you a lot sooner. That's a miss on my part. Just want to state that apology there for you. Okay, Randy. [5388] Jennifer Wingard: Oh yeah. Did you want to yes? Would you like to make your kind of next. It's convenient, yes. It's convenient. [5396] spk5: Larry Moles, I live with the baseball throwing distance to the end of the project. The first I heard was this morning. Somebody knocked on my door and gang. My wife's paperwork. my comments to this. Hey. I was the first trails committee chairman to currently. And we had a very difficult time putting together uses for all the different people that want to use currentwood wellness resources. It was very difficult. One of the trails we put in for non motorized use with Berg and Creek trail. Right down from the end of the project rowing drive all the way. I'm sorry, from the end of the project at Virgin Creek to Rouin Drive. The second thing is there's no way you're gonna get I ran the boarding chill for 16 years, and I will work with it for almost 27. I was involved in a lot of construction projects on Rice and Wayne in the road and off the road, et cetera. You're not gonna put that kind of a project in a ditch without cutting 30 foot swallow. I don't care what you say. I've seen construction, I know what construction equipment does, you know, right away when they're working. It's gonna tear the hell out of everything. Yeah, it's An area where you have significant number of trees that are hundreds of years old. Primary growth trees. I'm not a green, I'm not an environmentalist. I'm not an Indian. I've lived here since 86. I recognize communities have growth. They have needs need to be met, but there's processes in place, and the public should be involved. And they weren't in this. The application by star was on the 4th of May. The public comment went out on, I believe July the 6th. And the deadline is on the 20th of July. It's not acceptable. It's not what the public in Girdwood deserves. They need the right to have public notice and have time to think about it and work at it. Not in the middle of fishing season, not in the middle of vacation, but the 14 day comment period. I spent an hour just shy of an hour talking to DNR plan mining and water section today. The first words out of that individual's mouth. They're doing it to reinforce that area where they have low gas pressure. The second was for future development. Okay. The worst problem that we had with those projects was lack of transparency, which we found out later. A lot of the stuff they were saying just wasn't accurate. This would be the largest construction project that I had been aware of or seen since I've been here. The largest is gonna be huge. They're saying 20 foot swap, I'm saying 30 feet when you have equipment that's gonna take to day if there's no comment. I was told today if there's no comment by the public to DR by 5 p.m. on July 20. There will be people that might want comment in the future will not be allowed to. So if you want to be involved in this process, if you want to comment here further, you absolutely must apply your comment by the 5th by 5 p.m. on July 20. And I was told that by Division Landwork today. Well, I don't know anything about that. I said your question. Did you have any discussion about access roads? Only as it regards the future and potential development. So I would I wouldn't Respectfully that this board ask DR. And then the person who is gonna be responsible for approving or denying this project works for the DNR division of lands by you are to extend the public comment period for 60 days till people come back from vacation and their family stuff that they do in a shorter lasting summer, which this summer really appears to be very short. And then we can take it up and work with it. If it's been if it's been at least the time that I've been here, which is almost 40 years, surely they can wait another 60 days. And I'm gonna leave you with this. The comment period is 14 days, and within less than 30 days, you're gonna be digging dirt. You're gonna be cutting down trees that are hundreds of years old. And what you're gonna really do is make a lot of people that are in Girdwood who like me recognize the need for growth and change. You're gonna make it in. They're not gonna support anything. We've seen it a lot over the years. That's not what we want to do. We want to work together for these projects and make it work for everybody. If we need a gas fine, blue boo. It'll happen. But it needs to happen with all of us on the board. Now it's just a few people in a bureaucratic job. I'm not talking about you. Working with another bureaucracy or another two bureaucracies, because I didn't hear core engineers walk into this room. So now it appears DR, core of engineers, what and whoever else, as well as InStar. And we're gonna end up with a road. Yeah, I and I'm joined just enough and been here long enough to have a feeling. Yeah we have had this discussion about those in that area at least two separate times. And I suspect that's all [5854] Jennifer Wingard: right. [5856] spk5: Thank you. [5856] Jennifer Wingard: Thank you, Louis. Barbara was waiting forever, but I know your hand is down. I if you were still interested in telling me I'm sorry it took me so long, but please I do want to give you your opportunity now if you're still on. [5872] spk18: I'm here. Thank you. I'm Barbara Cruz, 285 Higher Terrace. Not speaking officially, but I am the chair of the trails committee, and yesterday was the first I heard about this gas line. I just would make a comment that we just spent three years working very hard on coming up with a trails master plan for the future. And I would say that the area that caused the most consternation and discussion, heated discussion amongst everyone, was this particular area. And we came up with some sort of compromise, but it took us three years to do it. And people have very strong feelings about this area, and at a minimum, I feel like we need to think about how why does that easement, how much can we like curve this or something within the easement. How much can we avoid the trails that are already there and preserve them and keep this thing out of sight if possible. I mean, if there was any way to mitigate it, I don't I mean, personally, I think it's a silly project to be doing right now. And as a rate payer, I don't want to be paying for this thing that's going to be obsolete in three years when we don't have gas. So you're still not going to be able to supply me with gas. But if we have to have this thing, if it can at least be taken into consideration how any way to make it more palatable. Thank you. Thank [5984] Jennifer Wingard: you, Barbara. At this point I need to do a check in with the board. We're getting close to an hour on this discussion. Sorry. Well I made it at 745. Yeah. Probably. So [6000] Brianna Sullivan: I would be happy to make a motion to extend this 15 minutes. [6006] Jennifer Wingard: I'm okay. So we have a motion to extend. Do we have any objections? Can I do this by consent? All right. So we'll extend the conversation until nine o'clock on this. And we take another comment from the room. Thank you. [6039] Brian Burnett: I would like to note though that previous N star projects coming up Valley dealing with boring and in proximity trail projects. We were very we had a close working relationship with N Star for the lower idea rod alignment. And they helped us get a survey center line survey inventory material resources we have around in that deck to the woods. I want to be able to. Getting some concessions on getting some additional trail resources from NSTAR as a as some sort of concession on this. As as Mr. Holmes pointed out, a 60 day grace period on the comment could buy us some time and it could also be time where insert come out and reevaluate the route going through do some trail surveys to see if there is a way so like previous comment came from from Ms. Cruz that that there might be a possible way of reconfiguring the alignment to be more audible to the community. So again, I'm not speaking in favor or in opposition of this right now, but I am pointing out that NSR has worked successfully with the community previously and helped this out in that part of the start of the valley is much different. [6138] Jennifer Wingard: Thank you. Thank you. I know we have some other comments in the room, and I do see thank you, Julie. Let me take one more from Brett online. [6149] spk7: thank you. Really quick question. Wondering if or the reason why a route from AW area at the end of Ruan, why the route towards the Coriolis alignment wasn't considered on the aerial photo if the route of that Coriolis drive alignment up to where like the number 17 is on Glacier Creek. And then making a hard right to the east would really minimize the impact to that high bench area. and it may it seems to me it would might bring other benefits to opening up that path as alternative. Exit from the South Townshite area as that gets developed. It would open up a bunch of possibilities there potentially. So the question is why was that route not considered for this project. [6212] spk1: You don't familiarize me with that. So the number 17 yeah can somebody point that to [6218] Brianna Sullivan: call, but he needs to go up here for this. This is alignment. So I don't know if it's only good, but it would go up there to where the end of or all the and then he said [6238] spk7: yeah from say the AW treatment plant up towards the Coriolis drive alignment and along that roadway alignment, and then take a hard right on the aerial diagram where the number 17 is in Glacier Creek, and then head east into the neighborhood. It seems like that would have less clearing impact than clearing a big wide swath through the high bench trees. I want to know why that path wasn't considered for this project. [6277] spk1: Existing lands. So the idea did come up in discussion spawner as being able to construct that project. I all I can do right now is take that comment back to our folks to get a response for you as to why that may not be third option. So can follow up with you on that. [6306] Jennifer Wingard: That'd be great. That'd be great. Did you have any oh sorry. [6314] spk12: Yeah, just to jump in on that real quick. So part of the problem with that alignment is coming out of the regulator station, we would you know the alignment now comes out of the red station splits off where the existing six inch trunk line runs. If we come off the existing trunk line and cross up further to the north, we still have the bottleneck of coming off just the existing single way feed trunk line. So that would we would still get some benefit of a two-way feed there. There wouldn't be any benefit of increased load for any sort of feature expansion. you wouldn't get your two-way loop wouldn't be quite as effective. That yeah, we'd have to confirm that the engineering department, but that's just off the top of my head, what I'm guessing there. [6369] spk7: You have to go east, you can't go north and then east, is what you're saying. I would suggest that if you went north and then east into the neighborhood, then you could reach the roadway and tie in to the rest of the red on that side in the eastern neighborhood. I would like to have maybe a little more detail as to why that route wouldn't be feasible, up Correol, as it brings extended benefits like roadway access, potential secondary access out from the Southtown site area. We have issues during forest fare. Anyway, look forward to an answer and I appreciate your response. Thank [6409] Jennifer Wingard: you. Thank you, Brennan. I'm Julie, I've seen your hand up and I see your hand up as well. Let me start with Janet, please. [6425] spk13: I had a couple follow-up questions and comments, and also would say that I would like to ask you boss to write a letter of objection to the ADL that's currently out there. And then I also support the majority of the comments from my neighbors. I don't support the comments about turning this into a trail. It would not be a trail. One thing it would not have a bridge over Glacier Creek. For another thing, it would be 20 plus feet wide, which is not a trail. In my opinion, it's a road. You said earlier that this part of the reasoning for this is because we're susceptible to damages. And you gave that one example of a contractor apparently not doing their due diligence and hitting a line. What other damages are we susceptible to at this point in time? we've gotten a couple different rationales for this proposal to counteract pressure loss in winter, which no one that we've talked to has experienced that to increase or to support increased Girdwood development. Still wondering where you guys have heard that from. You said earlier that this project is for the community. And I heard your apology, but I still find it pretty unbelievable that and Sar was willing to say that this is for the community when you haven't talked to us at all until you were invited here tonight. And first this proposal was and came up with it in April. then Zach said, actually, it's been a really long time, which to me is even more inexcusable that you haven't talked to the community before this point in time. I have a whole huge list of concerns about my personal property, which Brendan brought up earlier, as well as the forest itself. And honestly, I find it pretty astounding that you guys aren't able to address the issue that Mitch and a supervisor brought up about you know the long term sustainability of our natural gas future here in South Central Alaska. It's a disaster actually is what it is, our future, because won't get into the reasons. We ended up here with poor planning and whatever, but find it pretty astounding that you guys aren't willing to address that and how this project relates to it. Like one of my neighbors said, I'm also willing to suffer a loss of service as opposed to getting this project in. And I think you know, talking about risk and damage, it seems like the proposal is kind of irrelevant to any damage that happens outside of it. So I'm curious. Again, still why why this is needed absolutely right now that you guys feel like it has to start in a couple of weeks. Also, I wanted to mention that I own business, which utilizes that area on a regular basis. And it is absolutely critical to my business that that area maintain its natural natural character in order for my business to be able to continue to use that area, which I know and star knows absolutely nothing about. because you haven't talked to us. In terms of the actual sighting again, just to return to that quickly, you guys have said that you looked at other options that are not economical. I'd still really like to know what those other options were, especially because the municipality, when we were speaking with them, said that you guys had a whole other plan that was ready to go, and then actually accidentally came across the session line and we're like, oh, this is better. So I don't think we're getting [6638] spk34: the full story here on all of that. [6642] spk1: Yeah. I do have a design drawing for that that follows this. the extent of all the creek crossing for drive that it would have followed it almost in the same exact line over through the comments. So the same general rule was the first one submitted. And then it didn't do our due diligence for right away. That's one section. [6668] spk13: I need to see things on paper it's hard for me to understand described that way. I really feel like you guys are using kind of catastrophic language here to kind of make the community fear what might happen if we don't do this thing, which as Larry pointed out has not been necessary or had any catastrophes for the last 40 years. So again I I'm 100% opposed to this project and I hope you've also take action tonight to write a letter of objection to the state of us. And would be happy to hear answers to any of the questions [6701] Jennifer Wingard: we are now in a pretty limited window and I'm going to try to get in two more people here. So I've got Mary Jo in the room I'm trying that I've got Mary Joe in the room and Shelley Rotten all the way up already. Then we'll see what else we can fit in some there's [6715] spk19: my name is Mary Joe I'm in one six five Virgin Creek Road right across from Brennan and Julie. And had they not emailed me it's summer I don't check my mail often I would not know anything about this. And Star comes down there. At least weekly they could have at least put notices on people's doors they didn't bother they didn't notify anyone I don't think that with the shortage natural gas in our state that this is an intelligent thing to do it's expensive. You and I are going to end up paying a lot more because of this. And I would just like to ask the board of supervisors to please have a resolution or a letter opposing this, or at the minimum asking, as Larry said, for a 60 day extension. Let people in the community know nobody's around right now. And if we don't know about it. And this starts, you go down there and start clear cutting. You're you're going through my front yard. You're going through their half of their property. That's not accepted. You don't just show up and go, hey, this is what we're doing in two weeks. Like it's just wrong. And I am a ratepayer. I have natural gas. I love it. But you know what? If we have to do without it for a while, if there's an issue, that's like we'll make it work. But this is not acceptable. And giving us a two week giving us a three day notice, actually, that this has to be noted. We have to write something by the 20th. It's we can't do that. [6813] Jennifer Wingard: That's just wrong. So I would appreciate the board opposing this. Thank you. Okay. [6823] spk5: We have a beautiful seeding waterfall at the end of the road. Just the end of the road, you guys go for the falls. The traffic is unbelievable. People drive down that road as we speak. But there's probably half a dozen a day. The traffic is great. You put a road in that access area that he's talking about. It's gonna be a living hell and curve. It'll be a nightmare. [6854] Jennifer Wingard: Let me I did definitely want to get to Shelly because I told you I would. So you're on. [6860] spk38: Thank you. I didn't [6862] spk14: plan on speaking tonight, but as the only person here who has any knowledge from Heritage Land Bank previously, I feel like I need to speak. You know, the representatives from Instar said that this has been in the works from years. As the Heritage Land Bank land officer from May of 2019 to April of 2022. It's pretty amazing. I never once heard from a representative at N Star. Had I heard from a representative in Star, I could have suggested several different alternatives. And I never thought I'd say I agree with Brett Wilbanks, but I would have said, hey, let's go up through South Town site, provide gas to South Town site. There's already utility easements. It would advance the development of South Town site, and then you could cut over to the east and catch up with the timberline neighborhoods, and I don't see how that would reduce your loop. you still tie into the east, you know, and to say that you don't have the answers three days before the end of the comment period is obscene. I think you're trying to pull one over on the city on the town of Girdwood. And you should really be ashamed to come in here and say that you're here to listen. You're not here to listen. You're just here to save a little bit of face, and then just say you're gonna go on with this project. You're gonna go through old growth forests that cannot be replaced. You say you're gonna do 15 feet, but your written answer says 20 feet. You're gonna destroy the character of the Joe Danage Trail. You're gonna destroy the character of the Iditarod National Historic Trail. I doubt you've been in contact with the US Forest Service, have you? No, okay, you're going to destroy value of Heritage Land Bank wetlands. Are you gonna compensate them for that? Because they use that for compensatory mitigation [7000] spk1: I responded to that earlier, but yes, we're our installation within wells is pretty well defined in nationwide protocols. [7015] spk14: I could use nationwide permit 12, but that's not a really good neighbor answer. and Girdwood deserves a good neighbor in this situation when you're destroying some of the most valuable lands and recreational lands for them. that's really all I have to say. [7039] spk12: Okay, sure. When I say we've been looking at this project for a while, not necessarily not necessarily this alignment of pipeline I'm talking about. We've known it's something that we've been looking to do for a while. And I know you mentioned that yes, 20 feet is usually what we go clear. When I say we might be able to get away with 15 feet, that's me making an effort to minimize impact as much as possible. [7071] spk14: That's still too much in that forest. 1 feet is too much in that forest. [7079] Jennifer Wingard: Okay, thank you, Shelley. Super quickly, it looks like we have a sorry, Amanda. Do you have a question or a comment? [7087] spk11: No, I would like to make a motion. Are we ready for that? [7096] Jennifer Wingard: really quick so yes, please actually go go ahead and make the motion. We can make the motion and still have discussion. So make the motion, please. [7104] spk11: I move the Girdwood board of supervisors write a letter of objection to the N Star project. [7120] Brianna Sullivan: Okay, do we have a second second our discussion. [7130] spk44: Okay. [7131] Brianna Sullivan: And then one minute [7132] Jennifer Wingard: left. [7133] spk44: We have one minute left after that. Okay. [7135] Jennifer Wingard: Very quickly. Who else did I have in the room who did not get a chance to speak? Okay. [7141] spk1: Yeah. Yeah. Speak in favor of the motion to that. Really we need more time. I've not really been solved. I know that's doing their best to answer the questions, but they're decisions. They're just here to take those. This is a project that's going to cost millions of dollars. It's not requested by the customers. Yeah, it does address a potential risk, but we haven't heard that risk. We're going to be forced to pay for it because as reappears. They're not only saying they're going to capitalize it, which means it built into the rebacks. And then the regulatory machine we can that means the stock and start gets an investment. That's really not acceptable. That's unfortunate the rules. This is project really needed. What are the alternatives. Alternatives. Okay. Across the term. Sorry, but [7264] Jennifer Wingard: then we had a motion on the floor. And I would open it up for discussion among the board members. [7275] Brianna Sullivan: And I'll make a motion to go five more minutes for board member discussion for this motion. [7282] Jennifer Wingard: We need a second to that. Okay. All right. So no objections. We're going to take five more minutes to discuss the motion that's currently on the floor. [7293] Brianna Sullivan: I'll go ahead quickly to try to make quick comments. Even before this meeting began, I was already conflicted about this being and in the understanding that N star has every right to the easement and asking DNR for the permission and going through the process that they're doing now. And that meanwhile, all these incredibly valid concerns and solutions and proposed ideas are coming in at the last minute because it isn't the last minute, you just found out about it. And I would encourage everyone that has any interest to write their own letter with your great ideas, because if we just the body write a letter in two days that any of us isn't doing right now while we're at this meeting, it may mean nothing, not nothing, but it we don't have the power to stop this. But we can inject and we can say we we've like 30 more days, which I would at least say we write a letter to ask for an extension. So that we can come up with something better than what is on the screen in front of us. [7362] Jennifer Wingard: I agree with you, Brianna. You know, I permitted some actually gas line projects and you know nationwide permit 12. You can operate under that, and working with PIMSA, but that doesn't all happen overnight. Those are, you know, you know when you say I'm gonna work on a nationwide 12 and run off and do that, you know. Yeah, and then you have some plan, it takes planning too much to do that. And I know fins is not the quickest group in the world. So you know, discussions with them over the last month or year, you know, would have given you time to kind of do the community and communicate that. I do have some reservations about HDD under the streams. I mean it's not as clean and simple as that as it sounds. There are there definitely are environmental impacts and typically drilling mods and everything involved with that. So I would yeah, I support I would say you know at the very minimum increase the public comment period for another 30 days. I think there's alternatives to not squash project. I'm not even sure if there's a need for this project, but I did support the motion. Yeah, the very least increased the comment period for the 10 days. And then allow the community to meet that. I know it's tough to be explored right now. So [7449] Brianna Sullivan: and if I just to add on, if the comment is due by 5 p.m. Margaret, do you know if that's accepted it digitally? Yeah, to me now. Okay, [7463] spk1: sorry that's important. Maybe certainly thoughts more state or job. And although we told me it's comments, but it's only on section lines. Is that a guarantees that any requirements approvable? So just going to discuss this all meaningless because reality is scary, right? That's not exactly the job. [7495] Jennifer Wingard: Well, I've heard two different things talked about here. One is asking for an extension on the comment period, and the other is the motion that's actually in focus, which is to object. And those are those are actually kind of two different things, especially given the comment period. So if the comment period wasn't extended, then it sounds like we lose our window as G Boss to have input, although obviously the rest of the community is and I fully agree with Brianna, like the power of response here really we if you feel strongly about this needs to come from as many voices as possible. In that sense, GBOS alone doesn't have the power that multiple community voices have. Amanda, did you have a comment? [7547] spk11: I would be interested in revising my motion to either change to an extension of the comment period or include an extension of the comment period. [7562] Brianna Sullivan: I'll second the motion amendment and [7571] Jennifer Wingard: well I'm yeah, sorry, I'm a little unclear on what the motion is now so do we do we're [7579] Brianna Sullivan: motion was just to object. Well simply to object, and then we would feel comfortable with also adding in the extension, making sure that whoever writes this letter, if we pass this resolution that We're really also asking for an extension for [7599] Jennifer Wingard: asking for two things. Or sorry, two things are happening. We are asking for [7604] spk40: some motion. [7606] Brianna Sullivan: Correct. Right. No. Amanda mended her own. Right. Okay. Yes, Margaret. [7617] spk4: So my understanding of the motion is the GBOS would write a letter of objection to the An Star project and request an extension of the comment period for how long. [7629] Jennifer Wingard: Okay. And we have that moved and seconded, correct? And that is yeah. [7636] spk4: And so are we talking about 30 days or 60 days? [7639] Jennifer Wingard: 60. [7643] Brianna Sullivan: I would choose a number they would maybe be more amenable to. [7649] spk4: It's not 60, but kind of be in one month. Amanda. Amanda. [7655] spk11: 30 is better than two days for sure. So I yeah, I think 30 is a good request. Seems more likely to be accepted. [7666] spk4: Okay. So that's the motion that we currently have it. Two items, the letter of objection, in which there will be a request of an extension of the comment period for 30 additional days. August 20. Right. [7687] Jennifer Wingard: Do we have any further discussion? All right. [7696] spk4: Sure. I just was checking August 20 is Sunday. So we'd probably say August 21. Okay. Yes. So Breonna Sullivan. [7709] None: Yes. [7711] spk4: Jennifer Wingard? [7712] None: Yes. [7712] spk4: Hi Wayne? [7714] None: Yes. [7714] spk4: Amanda Sassy. [7716] None: Yes. [7718] spk4: Motion passes before to zero. So you know my next question. Right. [7732] spk11: I am raising my hand to offer being one of the people to work on this letter, if that's what the question is. [7740] Jennifer Wingard: That is what the question is. Thank you, Amanda. I'm [7744] spk11: traveling tomorrow, but I will work on it and try to send it to whoever else wants to do a review before it's sent to Margaret. First or you know, sending out to the rest of the board for review. Is that can we do it that way? I don't know for the open meetings act. If that's appropriate. [7769] Jennifer Wingard: And then the board gets to see what was written only in so far as it agrees with only for clerical. [7780] spk4: Yes in order to do that. [7781] Jennifer Wingard: Oh, I think we're agreed on what it needs to say, and I'm comfortable with to writing it. Unless members of the board disagree and feel that we need to be able to approach [7799] spk41: it. Oh do we need to be doing that? [7810] Jennifer Wingard: Amanda, I'll I can work with you on that. [7814] Brianna Sullivan: Great. Thank you [7816] Jennifer Wingard: very much. [7818] Brianna Sullivan: Thank you both. I don't have the availability in less than two days, but I'm happy to edit or send my notes to Margaret. [7828] Jennifer Wingard: Okay, thank you. Thank you to the room. That was the big discussion and it was handled very well. I very much appreciate that. We are moving on. Okay. Yes, it is. Thank you, Matter. Yes. Five minutes. Well, [7883] spk21: I think that's fine. So if I can help them five minutes, no no no no that's okay.